Colton sang "Can't Help Falling In Love" (in honor of Elvis' birthday) to Annie during the wedding ceremony while Annie sang a song she wrote for her dad and Colton during the reception. "I'm overwhelmed," Dixon told PEOPLE just after the ceremony. "There's so much joy!" Colton's sister Schyler also performed, singing "How Great Thou Art," while their uncle played piano.
Making the evening even more magical, Chapman performed his song "Cinderella" during the bride's Father-Daughter dance.